JoNova

A science presenter, writer, speaker & former TV host; author of The Skeptic's Handbook (over 200,000 copies distributed & available in 15 languages).


The Skeptics Handbook

Think it has been debunked? See here.

The Skeptics Handbook II

Climate Money Paper


Advertising

micropace


GoldNerds

The nerds have the numbers on precious metals investments on the ASX



The Thompsons

Could an honest hardworking couple emigrate to Australia with money, expertise, and create a popular and profitable business, but be destroyed by a few vocal activists with help from an government department? The government agreed with their plans, the Thompson’s followed every rule, broke no law, and there are no outstanding infringement notices, but the plans and rules kept changing. After they had put their money and hearts on the table the department added conditions that no one could meet, dangling them by a thread month after month as the Thompsons complied but the debts piled up. They passed all the tests, have local support, but they are being driven to bankruptcy by the Department of Environment and Conservation of WA.

Could this really happen in Australia? It’s a form of torture. Whatever happened to a fair go?

This page will be updated regularly

It will list all the main stories, articles and sources of information on the saga of The Thompsons.

Donations

Timeline

Petition in support

Narrogin wants them to stay

Shire pleads with govt

Media and Government Contacts are below  (See part 7 below)

Examples of letters (with email address of the WA parliament).

Photos for Media use (large resolution downloads)

Click to see a larger map.

Click for a large copy

————————

Media and Overseas interest

Calls, offers to help and donations are coming in from all over the world. People are appalled at the treatment the Thompsons have received. Australia’s sovereign risk is being discussed.

Watts Up With That has been providing fantastic support to The Thompsons in A Call To Action for the WUWT Community!

Donations raised in one week: $30,000 USD

Andrew Bolt linked to the You tube videos

Tim Blair finds the story compelling and convincing: Farm Aid


Background and information

1. Tyranny: How to destroy a business with environmental red tape

The summary | The history | A suicide | A question of undeclared conflict of interest | You tube videos where the Thompsons tell their story.

This post is a good place to start. Did you know in Australia it’s possible to ruin a business if you don’t like the way it smells? This is a heartbreaking story — that a government could effectively ruin a family by slowly strangling them in red tape, and that they would have apparently no protection from the courts.

————————

2. Smell that evidence

The studies on odour | The complaints | Comparison to other feedlots overseas

Cows and complaints don’t correlate. See the graph of the empirical evidence on the Thompsons case; the complaints, the cows, the recorded smells. Compare the Thompsons feedlot with others in the US which are 4 – 8 times larger and closer to towns.

Have the Thompsons been treated unfairly, are the complaints legitimate? Could we tell?
So let’s visit the empirical evidence…

————————

3. Four days notice! The Thompsons are served notice

The day the bank arrived to give them four days to pay

Have green government officials targeted a family farm because they are vocal skeptics?
This is a family with four young children, who ran a profitable business; they filled in every form and ticked every box. They have broken no laws, and there are no outstanding environmental notices, but yet, they came to Western Australia with their life savings and they are losing everything. After years of government red tape, delays, and impossible requests the bank has given them 4 days to pay up.

————————

4. Thompsons part 4: Every slope is a watercourse

We mock DEC’s use of the word “watercourse” | Maps | Aerial views

Click to see a larger map

See the ridiculous application of laws that are supposed to protect the environment. The Thompson’s case and all their pain depends on a paddock being listed as a watercourse. They have, in effect, lost it all because in a 100 year flood, water from this paddock might possibly reach a salt pan 10 km away. This is not about the environment. This post includes maps of the property and surrounds.

————————

5. Minister of the Environment and Queen of WA?

Tyrannical control through “licensing” with vague clauses

Here’s the key clause that pretty much gives total control over all businesses in WA to the Department of Environment and Conservation (DEC). Condition A1 is an all encompassing point recently added to the Thompson’s license. It’s a sweeping clause, and measured entirely with opinions. Anyone with the right to say Yay or Nay to what is “unreasonable” is effectively the ruling monarch.

————————

6. Thompsons part 6: Strong Community Support

Narrogin wants the Thompsons to stay

Narrogin is a town of around 5,000 people.  In April 2007, 900 people signed a petition in support of them, and their two nearest neighbors have written letters declaring it’s a valuable business and they want the feedlot to stay and grow. The support is not just that the feedlot should operate at 10,000 head, they all put their names to increasing it to 15,000. Locals give Matt money in the street and tell him to fight on, the complainants live further away than the strong supporters (who say the odour is no problem), and the piggery was operating right next door for all those years before The Thompsons even started and before the neighbours moved in.

————————

Thompsons Part 7: Welcome to Investment Hell

Examples of letters to politicians, editors and news outlets.

See also This list of WA politicians.

——————————-

Thompsons Part 8: Mexican standoff at the Farmgate

See all my posts tagged Matt and Janet Thompson. (This link will always be up to date, whereas the latest stories may not appear on this page you are viewing for a while.)

——————————-

Thompsons Part 9: Senator Cory Bernardi speaks out in Parliament

Senator Bernardi is not even a Senator from the same state as the Thompsons, yet he has gone out of his way to find out some of the information behind the case, and raised the issue in Parliament. It’s the mark of a man of principle.
Senator Cory Bernardi is a Senator for South Australia.

——————————-

Thompsons Part 10: The DEC admits it treated them unfairly

This comes from the DEC’s itself: they have a standard procedure, and they didn’t follow it for the Thompsons.
Here are what I believe are the most damning critical passages of the whole Thompson case, and they come from the minutes of a meeting with DEC and the Thompsons held in December 2009.

——————————-

Dirty tactics? Fences cut at the Thompsons…

1. Dirty Tactics |  2. FarmOnline Media |  3. Mini-update

Yesterday Matt and Janet were horrified to find that someone had cut the wires on the perimeter fence. There was no evidence anyone had taken anything, nor do we know who did it.  An unrelated random crime, or, who knows — someone hoping to spook [...]

——————————-

DEC, deceptive, duplicitous, or just clueless about money?

The DEC fight back with deception, bogus licenses (that no bank will loan money against), ask for things that have already been done, and turns a blind eye to the killer fine print clauses that make them kingmakers with veto rights over any business in the State. This is a PR war.

——————————-

Funeral for Property Rights

UPDATED: Dates for the West Australian Speaking Tour below The Thompsons protest on Monday was moving. Janet Thompson delivered one of the best speeches I’ve heard at a protest. I was going to copy parts of it and attach the full speech in documents. But so much is worth saying, I’ve put it here almost in entirety.

——————————-

The Thompsons have spent most of 2011 in legal battles against both the NAB and the DEC.

DEC replies: All they have are unpublished complaint-mail and an unbankable license.

Breakthrough: DEC ‘s all-purpose (green) business licence

This post explains why the current license is unbankable and unworkable. DEC can pretend to “help” business and be “Green” at the same time. No business could run with this license.

Update from the Thompsons: The legal limbo drags on: Dec 1 2010

 

Farmers fighting for a fair go. Updates on The Thompsons and Peter Spencer: July 2011

 

 

 

——————————-

The Narrogin Community Library has links to the Thompsons case

To read hundreds of comments on this case, see the links above.

(Comments were not accepted on this page until a software change in October 2011.)

Updated Dec 2011.

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 6.0/10 (4 votes cast)
The Thompsons, 6.0 out of 10 based on 4 ratings

4 comments to The Thompsons

Leave a Reply

  

  

  

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>